I haven’t yet publicly posted the last two parts of my story on this blog.  I’m checking my motive before I do that.  Because, while all the names have been changed and only one person that knows me personally is following this blog (and I suspect has shared it with church leadership), I want to be sure that when I post it publicly, it is not to hurt, but to help others to heal.

From the beginning of my story, with that church, that pastor, and other leadership, I know that my motivation was to help.  Without giving it away here, I was involved in a volunteer capacity in which I became intimately aware that the leader was diminishing those who were serving under him.  Because I so wanted this leader to be successful, I began the process of Matthew 18.  I was his “chief volunteer” you might say, working closely with him for several months, so I was comfortable speaking with him about my concerns.  Several times.  Nothing changed. And his behavior continued to create angst amongst the other volunteers.

So, again with the motive of helping him to understand and redirect, I went to leadership.  From there, the situation spiraled out of control.  From there, everyone began saying that I was the problem for pointing out the problem.  And it didn’t make sense to me.  Because in my heart, I knew that my motive was to help.  I wanted this person to be successful.  I wanted the other volunteers to be built up and well-prepared for the ministry in which we were involved.

Instead, I was told that I could no longer serve under that leader.

And as time went on, I was told I could not do lots of other things in the church.  Each time I received these messages, I asked “Why?” and was never given a specific answer.  I would also ask (if I wasn’t told directly) if the senior pastor was aware of this decision.  Always, I was told that he was.  So I would email him and ask, “What have I done?  Why was this happening?  How can you allow this?”  My motive was to follow Matthew 18.  And since the senior pastor was always named, I always went directly to him.

Finally, the day came when I was stopped on the sidewalk on a Sunday morning as hundreds of people were leaving the church, and told that I could not be involved in serving, attending classes, or doing anything except to sit in the services.  As with every other time I was told I “couldn’t,” I asked “Why?”  This assistant pastor refused to tell me citing “legal ramifications.”

From then on, I repeatedly asked the senior pastor, who had again been named in this decision, all of the “Why?” “What have I done?” “How can you preach grace and truth when you know this is happening to me?” questions.

Never a response.

And we all know that no response is a response.

The message I was receiving was that I was the problem and I didn’t deserve so much as a Matthew 18 process. I didn’t deserve to even know what I was accused of.  And I believed it.

I know that might sound crazy to some of you reading this, but when you have been shamed and abused for as long as I was – over 20 years in two different churches – and had heard all of the scripture references that supported being told that I was not even acceptable to God, well, I guess you just have to have been there . . .

Anyway, back to motive.  I know my motive.  My heart has always been to ask for help.  My heart has always been to extend help.  My heart has always been to find healing.  And now, my heart is to share my story so that others who read it might know they are not alone, or might recognize the abuses going on in their own churches – or perhaps that they are perpetrating.  My heart is to offer those who know someone who has been abused direction in how to help them heal.  My heart is to help and to heal.

And I must ask myself, what was the motive of the leadership at the church?  Was there any attempt to help me?  I can’t see it.

Was there any attempt to bring healing to me?  (In my head this is being answered with a whisper) “No.”

Did anything come of the way that I was treated besides deep wounds, shame, and inexplicable pain?  “No.”

If I am wrong, I would really appreciate it if someone would, with the motive of promoting help and healing, help me to understand.

  1. I can’t and shouldn’t try to judge your heart, but I deeply resonate with it. I have an article that I have written about my own experience of abuse that I have still not been able to post. As carefully as I have crafted it to protect the identity of those who hurt me, I still struggle before God to know how best to handle my story. I am finished with trying to protect them from the consequences of their own decisions. On the other hand, I hope I am never finished with Jesus’ call for me to love them. Whether they fall under the category of brothers or of enemies, I am not released from loving them. Your insistence on holding on to this tension makes me respect you all the more.

  2. If you spend too long worrying about your motives, you never do anything at all. Matthew 18 is, or should be, a wonderful recipe for resolving church disputes. Unfortunately I’ve never yet come across a church that takes it seriously.
    Since your posts contain no names or places or clues as to the identity of the people involved, they are entirely harmless to these people.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s